![]() |
|
||||||||||||||
| Appraisal ID: | 90710 | |
| Appraised On: | 20-10-2005 | |
| Title: | Middleton Silver Co. Candelabra | |
| Date/Era/Period: | 1899-1920? | |
| Item URL: | Click Here To View | |
| Description: | A silver plated candelabra made by the Middleton Silver Co. (Not the Silver PLATE Co.!) It is marked "MAN'F'D AND GUARANTEED BY MIDDLETON SILVER CO. 027 Quadruple." It has 6 candle holders, five of them the holder itself unscrews from the branch. It also has six removable wax guards. It has finely beaded pattern around base and on various other parts.the arms that attach the candle holders to the center are beautifully looped. | |
| Condition: | This is in really good condition. I don't know enough to say it is almost perfect but it certainly looks really good, in fact striking. Right where one of the loops attaches to the middle-it looks like the loop may have been soldered because it is rough and dark with a pin head sized drop of green. This is about 1/8 of an inch or a little more and is not really noticeable. One of the wax guards has minute scratch and a few black spots. Couple tiny dents on bottom. On base there is about inch and 1/2 series of very narrow black marks-1/16th of inch or less wide. I had to keep turning it to even see them. | |
| Origin: | Bought this from estate sale. Woman selling it had no idea where it came from. | |
| Provenance: | No. I only know that this must have been made by former employees of Middleton Silver Plate when they founded their own company in about 1899. Of the few pieces of Middleton Silver Co. I could find on the internet, none had the same inscription as this piece. Few things are listed for Middleton Silver( not Plate) Co. Could find no candelabra. | |
| Appraised By: | Bruce Taylor |
| History Of The Item: |
A determination of history and value will be confronted with your comprehensive inquire of information, photographic illustrations and a transparent image of a silversmith’s logo, symbol, trademark, brand or signature, distinguishing the piece as follows: Renderings depict a single silver plate candelabra, *attributed to and is inscribed, MAN'F'D AND GUARANTEED BY MIDDLETON SILVER CO. 027 {a pattern or Style Number} Quadruple (plate 4/100 to 8/100 of an inch thick}, consisting of 6 candle holders, 5 removable upper arm or branches, six removable wax guards, finely beaded pattern around base and on various other parts. the arms that attach the candle holders to the center are beautifully looped, circa 1890. |
| Appraiser Tips: |
The company was formed in 1864 to manufacture silver plate and Britannia ware, was originally located in Middletown, but moved to Medidenn when it was bought by International Silver Company. The company mark was changed to reflect the new locations, so a rough dating is possible. by 1898, was simply a trademark used within the larger conglomerate. From the beginning, the company put out a huge range of goods, from elaborate tea sets to individual salt spoons and everything in between. One specialty, for which they held numerous design patents were ice water pitchers. While most goods were either Britannia metal or silver plate, a limited amount of sterling was made. All sterling goods carried a special mark stating it was 925/1000 silver; if it does not, then it is either plate or Britannia. Now we open a Pandora’s box of silver companies in Connecticut 1850’s? The Meriden Britannia Company was formed in 1852 in Meriden, Connecticut. The Rogers Bros firm was purchased by Meriden Britannia in 1862, thereby acquiring the 1847 Rogers Bros line. In 1878, they had a store at Union Square in New York City and a manufacturing facility in West Meriden, CT. According to their 1878 catalogue, the company won a first place medal at the 1876 Centennial Exhibition in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania for the "large variety of silver plated white metal hollow ware, of excellent quality and finish, and of tasteful designs." They were one of the original companies that joined together to form the International Silver Co. in 1898. The International Silver Company, an amalgamation of independent silverware manufacturers, was formed in New Jersey November 19th. 1898. Many of these manufacturers were the result of previous consolidations and mergers. The member companies kept their identities and continued to mark silverware with their own touch marks. In addition an International Silver mark was used on products sold by the parent company. International Silver traces its heritage back to Ashbil Griswold, who established a pewter shop in Meriden, Connecticut in 1808. Under Griswold's leadership, Meriden soon became a leading center in the production of Britannia ware, pewter, and silverware. In nearby Hartford, three brothers, Asa, Simeon, and William Rogers, opened a workshop to manufacture coin silver silverware. As the cost of coin silver rose, the brothers conducted electroplating experiments. By 1847 they had perfected the process and issued their first electroplated silverware under the name of Rogers Bros. The company introduced Olive, the first fancy electroplate flatware pattern made from start to finish in America. Because of its more durable qualities, Britannia had replaced pewter in most American homes by the 1850s. H. C. Wilcox & Co., Meriden, was one of the leading manufacturers of this new ware. In 1852, The Meriden Britannia Company was organized. In 1862, it purchased Rogers Bros. and moved the company from Hartford to Meriden. By the 1890s, Meriden Britannia had established branches in Canada and London and sales offices in Chicago, New York, and San Francisco. Assuming a leadership role, Meriden Britannia convinced other small independent silver shops in the Connecticut area that cooperation was more efficient. The International Silver Company was the result. The Meriden Wallingford, Connecticut area became the American silverware manufacturing center by 1900. International Silver's Joan of Arc and Prelude patterns proved to be popular in their introduction and are among the most desired of the company's products. Production reached its peak in the late 1940s. International Silver has been marketed aggressively since its 1898 formation. In 1968, International Silver became part of Insilco, itself a large conglomerate. In 1972, International silver spun off its hotel division as an independent subsidiary, World Tableware International. A group of private investors purchased World Tableware in 1983 and organized the American Silver Company. Original companies forming the International Silver Company 1898; American Silver Co., Barbour Silver Co., Forbes Silver Co., Holmes & Edwards Silver Co., Bridgeport La Pierre Mfg. Co Leonard Silver plate, Chelsea, Massachusetts, to Towle Silversmiths in 1978 Manhattan Silver Plate Co., Lyons New York Middleton Silver Company. Meriden Silver Plate Co., Meriden Norwich Cutlery, Norwich C. Rogers & Bros., Meriden Rogers & Hamilton Co., Rogers, Smith & Co., Standard Silver Company, Ltd. (Toronto, Canada). Simpson Nickel Company (Wallingford Watrous Mfg. Co., Wallinford Webster Mfg. Co., Wilcox Silver Plate Co, Meriden Wilcox & Everster, William Rogers Mfg. Co. Hartford During the first six months of 1899, an additional four companies were purchased. Derby Silver Company (Derby), Simpson, Hall, Miller & Company (Wallingford), Simpson Nickel Company (Wallingford), Middletown Plate Company (Middletown). Silversmiths use a variety of techniques for decorating the surface of the silver itself, either by cutting metal from, applying it to, or manipulating the surface of the object. One of the earliest and simplest techniques for decorating silver is engraving, extracting thin filaments of silver with a sharp tool to form a decorative pattern on the surface of the metal. The graver is a diamond-shaped steel rod, set in a wooden handle; the rod’s end is cut off diagonally, giving a sharp point to the cutting edge. Until the mid-sixteenth century engraving on European and English silver was somewhat crude, but by the late sixteenth century it had become highly refined and was used to carry out entire pictorial compositions. Engraving was also favored for heraldic work, following a universal code, fine lines and dots. Ornamental and protective plate is very thin, usually from 1/1,000 to 2/1,000 of an inch (0.03 to 0.05 millimeter) thick. Quadruple plate would be 4/100 to 8/100 of an inch thick, For plating gold, silver, copper, zinc, and cadmium, cyanide solutions of the same metals are often used. Copper and zinc may also be plated by acid-sulfate solutions. Chromium is plated with a chromic-acid solution and nickel is plated with nickel sulfate. Other metals plated for commercial use include platinum, lead, and tin. Alloys of two or more metals may be deposited by using a solution of salts of the metals that make up the alloy. Examples of alloys used for plating are brass, black nickel, lead-tin, and bronze. |
| Research Sources: |
A tidbit of Histoty; Sterling Silver candelabra dating prior to the reign of George III are rare. As prosperity increased during the second half of the 18th. century, the silver was made heavier and massive candelabra were not uncommon in the great houses throughout the land. The nineteenth century produced many magnificent specimens with three or five lights, and occasionally one finds an important pair made for a large dining hall with as many as twelve lights. Candelabra for the most part followed the designs used in candle sticks during the Queen Anne period. The prevailing patterns had three branches radiating from a center stem which was surmounted by a molded finial. During the rococo period, twisted branches were not uncommon and the finial center was frequently replaced by a socket. No doubt because of the excessive cost of silver candelabra many more pairs were made in Sheffield plate. The authenticity of this candelabra is assumed prima facie. I do not warrant or guarantee the authenticity, title or ownership of the subject property. All information and/or representations made by the owner(s) or representative(s) are assumed to be true and correct to the best of their knowledge and belief and are established as such.All too often rarity is "in the eye of the collector". Rarity is a word with kaleidoscopic meaning when applied, but certainly true rarity, is an essential factor in this evaluation. The term does not necessarily denote how many of something exists. It can indicate how many are available. Prices for this category of antique lighting are in the $339.00 {FMV} to $399.00 {RV} range. The two values prearranged, envision differing scenarios. The fair market value {FMV} assumes that the piece(s) might be sold at an estate sale, auction, or reduced by as much as 50% if sold to a dealer. The replacement value {RV} reflects what one might have to pay to substitute the item(s) with a similar piece. This [RV} figure is to use for insurance purposes. The two numbers characteristically are quite a distance apart given the different markets they refer to. A selling value somewhere in the course of the two would be an acceptable result. Provenance, and Condition is Paramount; Collectors look for pieces in good condition, with the original surface, and it is important that a piece has not been "cleaned", this meaning repainted, marred, under some conditions re-stored, and the like, with a provenance and/or known maker if at all possible. Good pieces can stand on their own however information about the history of a piece, especially about the maker, is what collectors are always looking for, yet good examples, with even minor excuses, or parents appeal to a limited market at best. In truth, the buyers for the best work by known makers are still very concerned with original condition. As is always true, the continuing impact of today’s on-line auctions shows in the listings, again, creative originality is what is driving the market, as in real-estate location, location, location. The range between a piece in good condition and an excellent or original condition example continues to widen. It is imperative the importance of detail and completeness. This appraisal is offered with no known contingent or limiting conditions that would affect the values stated. I have no present of future financial interest in the appraised property. This appraisal assignment and compensation is in no way contingent upon the appraised valuations. Unless otherwise stated herein, this appraisal was based on the readily apparent identity of the property appraised. Neither further opinion nor guarantee of authenticity, genuineness, attribution or authorship is made. All stated identities and associated values are conditional on an "as represented" basis. The method of evaluation used to determine the fair market value is the approach and was based on a comprehensive study of the primary and secondary market. Included but not limited to, were prices realized at auction, Internet sites, current price indexes and printed price lists, phone calls to wholesalers, galleries, and retailers handling or representing the same item. The values expressed herein are based on my professional judgment. This evaluation is not a warranty that the property will realize that value if offered for sale. The values articulated were based on current information on the date of this evaluation, and no opinion is hereby expressed as to any future value nor, unless otherwise expressly stated, as to any past value. The appraisal report should be reviewed and updated periodically; it is recommended that such reconsideration take place every five years.
|
| Appraiser Comments: |
Attributed to Middleton Silver Company circa 1890 The consensus of informed opinion on the origin, authorship, and date of an object is termed its attribution. In a few cases a history exists which puts the correct attribution beyond doubt. Obviously a piece accompanied by an invoice, which has been in a particular place since it was made, can reliably be attributed to a particular workshop, and even if the invoice were not dated, the article itself could be placed to within a few years by its fashion. Most antiques and many things which might be defined as works of art, have no reliable history, and often they have passed from hand to hand for so long that it is now impossible to trace them to their original source. In such cases an attribution must be made on the available evidence, that is to say the piece itself. This is an assignment for the specialist accustomed to such judgments, since many factors need to be weighed and considered. Someone of sufficient experience often finds it easy to make an attribution on the basis of analogy with other known examples, and perhaps most attributions are made in this way. To do this ultimately depends on the existence of key pieces with a reliable history of one kind or another with which the un-attributed object may be compared, and for the vast number of antiques this is adequate. Occasionally difficult problems present themselves, and the final verdict is then arrived at by process of elimination. By discarding what it could not possibly be, we eventually arrive at what it could be. The first question to be decided is whether the object is as old as its style suggests or a later copy or a forgery. Most such things can usually be dated {when they are genuine} from the style, and technique will usually suggest a country of origin. It then remains to be considered whether sufficient evidence exists to venture an attribution to a particular source. It is always alluring to accept marks at their face value, and the question of their reliability is an aid to attribution they should only be accepted as confirmatory evidence when everything else is seen to be in agreement. The easiest part of any forgery is usually the addition of a signature or maker’s mark. Many of the books listed in the bibliography are illustrated, and good photographs and illustrations are of considerable assistance in suggesting possible sources for a piece of which the attribution is in doubt. Mere resemblance however is not enough because craftsman copied each other’s paradigm and drew inspiration from published books of designs. It must also be remembered that research is still going on into many of the categories, and that this may result in changes of attribution in the future. This change in attribution has meant, if anything, an increase in value for the secedent group although this is not always the case. Attribution in certain instances, therefore, must not be regarded as fixed and immutable however the most likely statement of the facts in the light of what is known at the time. In the vast majority of cases however no change is likely which will significantly alter either value or attribution. The above statistics corroborate, and do imply authenticity, this piece is without restoration penalties, certainly not apocryphal, kitsch, a hybrid or even a red herring, far be it {from me} to be backward, when admiration for this antique lighting paradigm is in order, we express our gratitude to you for your time and persistence in submitting images, from our independent organization here in the great lakes region of North America., USA. I, Bruce L. Taylor, AOA 63378, USAF retired, an antiquarian, am your assigned enthusiastic independent senior evaluator. Research complete, 9:45 AM, EST, October 20, 2005, thank you for your interest in our on-line valuation service. |
|
|||||||||||
|
This online appraisal is an expert's opinion of the item(s) depicted above based solely on images and information supplied by our customer. Additional information, not shown on this certificate, may have been taken into account for this online Appraisal. Please Note: Our service strives to include the best international authorities in their respective fields. While the appraiser may be an expert in rendering the valuation, please understand that they may not be completely fluent in English. * Current Fair Market Value is the amount someone might receive when selling their item to a dealer or at auction. It is also the amount most government tax agencies (IRS, Revenue Canada, Inland Revenue, etc.) recognize as the tax deductible amount were the item donated to a charitable organization. ** Replacement Cost is the retail amount one might reasonably pay to purchase the item from a dealer, gallery, store, etc. It is also the amount for which one may want to insure an item. For currency conversion go to http://www.xe.net/ucc/full.shtml Whatsitworthtoyou.com |
||